When Is It OK to Increase Spending?
I was making the rounds on my reading yesterday and came across an interesting post by Lazy Man and Money. In it he mentions that a full-time opportunity has come up that will net him more money so he’s no longer going to be blogging full-time. But, what I really liked about the post was the lesson that even finance bloggers still face the same issues as everyone else when it comes to increased spending. I certainly wish LM well in his pursuits!
What I wanted to talk about, though was the idea of increased spending. One of the commenter’s on LM’s blog said that increased spending is ok if your income increases, much the same as your spending would decrease if your income decreased. The point I believe he was trying to make was that it’s still about living within your means. The amount of money you spend isn’t really the factor, and whether or not it increases or decreases depends entirely on what your means are.
What an interesting concept! We beat ourselves up if we spend more than we think we should, wouldn’t it be nice not to worry about it? Of course, I’m not advocating that we should increase spending for the sake of increasing spending. I still believe that we need to live within our means and live responsibly to avoid future debt. But, if we’re funding our retirement accounts, have 3-6 months saved in an emergency fund, and have no debt – like LM – should we really be concerned with a small influx in consumer spending? Especially when we’re making more money?
I think not.
Increased spending can be dangerous, though. If left unchecked, it would be very easy for anyone to rack up credit card debt, drain their emergency funds, and generally blow through their higher income. So, while I like the general idea of having the freedom to do a little more with that higher income, I also say that it can get out of hand if you let it.
As LM said, even though finance bloggers and those who are financially savvy are aware of the psychological triggers, it doesn’t make us immune to them. We get caught up in impulse buying just like everyone else. But, we can usually avoid overspending by sticking to our principles. And, one of the biggest holes that needs fixing in any budget is lack of planning. As LM experienced, and I’m really bad about this too, it’s the forgetting to plan ahead that can sometimes catch us in a spending trap. For example, forgetting to pack your lunch, make your morning coffee, or other things you could avoid by planning ahead.
Still, at the end of the day, if you’re making more money, these unexpected expenses from lack of planning are really not that big of a deal. In the end, I want to remember that I lived a long full life, not that I micromanaged my finances so much that I berated myself for lunch out occasionally. Some of you may disagree, and if you’re in debt, I totally understand. I was there once, too. I micromanaged every aspect of my spending. But, if the basics are taken care of and there is no debt, what’s the point of living frugally if you can’t enjoy the fruits of your labor occasionally?
So, what it amounts to is this. Yes, I think if you’re making more income it is ok to spend more money – within reason. I do not believe it is wise to go hog wild, as the saying goes, but having a lunch out a few times a week probably isn’t going to break you. The key to this, as with anything, is moderation and living within your means.
Thoughts? Do you think if you’ve been living a frugal lifestyle on one income that you can afford to spend a little more if that income increases? Or, are you of the opinion that this is a bad thing?
Related posts:

I think if you generally are a frugal person, then you can afford to blow a little more from time-to-time. My wife and I have gone a bit Wii crazy lately, probably spending ~$500 on a Wii and accessories in the past month. I think we usually do a pretty good job of saving, so I don’t feel too bad about letting loose.
I don’t plan an increase in lifestyle as our incomes increase, but it’s tough to avoid. My hope is that our savings also increases, so that everything is in moderation.
-1MansMoney
I always wonder why people naturally increase their spending usually in higher proportion when they make more money.
Say they get a raise of a few thousands, and then they go out buy a new car.
I mean that clearly makes no sense, I mean did they really calculate the costs associated with this new job. Maybe its more hours to work, relocating.
And now compare that to the increase in income you get each month, which may only be a few hundred dollars while your car payment may also be a few hundred dollars.
So right there you just signed away 5 years of your life to paying the car off.
I think it’s OK to spend a little bit more than usual every now and then as long as it does not become a habit. The key is I guess is not to feel guilty about it.
Money is a means to an end, not an end itself. If you are on track to meet all your goals in a time frame that makes you happy, feel free to blow the rest of your cash on whatever the heck you want. Money is only a tool. It’s wonderful if you have it and take care of it and use it. It’s a waste when it sits there gathering dust. Remember the past, plan for the future, but live in the present.
I am totally for increasing spending, unless it means going back into debt. However, as long as your goals are met and are continuing to work for you, if your money increases, go ahead and spend some of it. I would only be concerned if the spending wasn’t being paid for in cash – or put on a credit card that was paid off at the end of the month.
Sure! It’s totally fine to increase spending when income increases… So long as you budget for it. If the increased spending – be it eating out, entertainment, clothes – is accounted for, planned for, given a name, then I don’t care what you spend it on. The point of the budget is making the conscience decision to spend that money – on paper, on purpose.
Last year, when our income went up, we were able to save more as well as add a line item for date night (a big hit) and bump up a couple other categories. Nothing wrong with it, so long as it doesn’t get in the way of your goals.