Home » Credit Cards

The Cost of Being a Good Friend

Submitted by Kristy on March 17, 2009 – 7:44 am28 Comments

You know, after this experience, I don’t think I’ll ever want to be a maid of honor again. I love my friend, but I had no idea that being in her wedding was personally going to cost me so much!

First of all, my friend and her fiancé don’t have a lot of money and they didn’t spend a lot of time saving for the wedding. In fact, her wedding budget was like $3000 – not counting the rings. It’s also a very small wedding and there’s only four of us in the wedding party – the bride, groom, best man, and myself as the maid of honor. But, because my friend didn’t have a lot of money, she is expecting me to buy my own dress and shoes, pay for my hair and nails – which I have to have done because of the pictures – and other little miscellaneous expenses.

Now, a coworker at work is getting married and she thought it was crazy that I had to pay for all of that myself. I didn’t mind because I knew their budget was tight. However, I got a little frustrated when I found out they’re paying for the best man’s tux rental. His tux is about $100. My dress was $135. I would have been fine paying the $35 if all she could do was $100. But, I find it ridiculous that I’m expected to pay for all of that stuff myself, while the best man gets his tux rental, including shoes, paid for him.

Her reasoning was that they knew they could depend on me to do what I was supposed to do for the wedding, but the best man is somewhat flaky. Edward has known this guy since high school, so he is his best friend, but he’s not reliable at all. They’re also trying to get the guy to stay the night at their house the night before the wedding so they can make sure he’s on time. I found that kind of strange, but ok, whatever. I’ll pay for my stuff and leave it at that.

Well, it gets better. Turns out, I’m supposed to host the bachelorette party and my friend wants to do it somewhat wild. She’s got seven friends, counting myself, that she wants to invite, so I figure if they all pitch in $20-30, I can plan something really nice. I expected that I would pay the bulk of the money for this since it’s her special night and I wanted her to have a good time. So, my plan was to have dinner at the restaurant her fiancé proposed to her at, then take a limo downtown to an upscale club where I’ve reserved tables for us. Total cost?

  • Dinner – $50
  • Limo for 4 hours – $300
  • Club reservation – $300
  • Cocktail dress – $90

Grand total – $740

I don’t actually own a cocktail dress, so that’s why I bought one. The club itself is pretty cool. The fee includes our own VIP tables near the DJ booth, a bottle of alcohol and mixers where our personal cocktail waitress will make the drinks at our table. If anyone wants something else to drink, she will go to the bar and get them for us. We’ll also have fruit and other little snacks to go with it, and it will be pre-decorated for us. So, all in all, that $390 was well-spent.

The limo I’m still iffy about. Frankly, I didn’t want to have to worry about getting seven other drunk women home. I figured the limo would be the easiest way to do that. But here’s the thing. Of all the people I’ve talked to, only one said they would go downtown with us. The rest aren’t sure they can make it. Everyone is willing to do dinner, but to go downtown is a different story. Of course, no one had any qualms with it until I asked for $20-30 or whatever they could spare. Suddenly that weekend they’re all going out of town.

So here I am, planning this bachelorette party that I was sort of guilted into planning anyway, and her so-called friends are backing out because I’m asking for a little money to cover the expenses. I really don’t think $20-30 is a lot, and I didn’t make it a requirement. I was just hoping for some support. But, on the other hand, I feel bad for my best friend because now these people aren’t going to be there for one of the most important events in her life. I say that with a grain of salt, but you know what I mean. She’s been looking forward to this for months. And, I won’t tell her the plan, so she has no idea what I have in store.

As it stands, there’s three of us for sure going downtown. Most everyone else will be going to dinner, though. So, what I’m thinking is that I can modify it to make it cheaper. I’ll keep the club reservation because, honestly, I’m excited about that, too. I’ll skip the limo and just rent a hotel room downtown where we can safely get from the club to the hotel in one piece. That’s a plus too because with the limo, we’d be cutting the night short so I didn’t get charged anything extra. With the hotel, we don’t have to worry about it. But, the hotel is probably going to be about $175 for the night as it’s a Saturday. So, in total, I’d only be looking at about $615. But, it will probably be a little more when you calculate tip and any extra drinks we might have.

I’m just whining a little here, but being the bride’s best friend is turning out to be way more expensive than I thought it would be. I’m sure we’ll have a great time, but I’m disappointed that this all falls on my shoulders alone. I sort of expected her other friends to pitch in on this and they’re not. The grand total I’ve spent on this wedding, including my dress, hair, nails, and bachelorette party comes to about $1000. I think that’s a lot for a wedding that’s only costing them $3000. But, maybe I’m just being stingy with my money. I’ve worked hard to save it and I’m finding it difficult to part ways with it when I don’t really feel like the effort is being appreciated. I feel like my friend is just taking for granted that I would do this.

Am I just being a selfish penny-pincher here, or does this seem like a lot of money and effort to heap on someone you’ve asked to be in your wedding. What would you do in this case?

Related posts:

  1. The Cost of Owning Pets
  2. How NOT to Use a Corporate Card – 4 stories that will make your head spin!
  3. My friend Tom
  4. Cool Contest Over At A Friend’s Blog
  5. The Sunk-Cost Fallacy

28 Comments »

  • Courtney says:

    Hate to tell you this but you’re responsible for the bridal shower too. That’s in addition to the bachelorette party. When my best friend got married, it cost me over $2K.

    Oh, and don’t forget a gift too!

    Being a bridesmaid totally sucks.

  • 444 says:

    Sorry to be a grouchy old scrooge, but whatever happened to having a wedding that’s actually affordable? Limos and clubs? Hello?!

    Not criticizing your planning or your ideas. But the fact that you are footing the bill for your friend who cannot afford this is just so twisted. In my world, anyway. I never thought that a modest wedding was anything shameful. I guess I just live in a different world than most people, though.

  • Jeeze! I would be complaining too if I were you.

    We had a small wedding (25 guests) that cost us about what your friend is paying. I had two bridesmaids, I let them wear whatever they wanted. Same with the groomsmen. I mean, if you want a small inexpensive wedding then you can’t really expect all the hoopla that goes along with big wedding. I didn’t have a shower, or a bachelorette party.

    Can you be honest with your friend? It seems like someone who is being frugal with their own money would understand where you are coming from.

  • Christine says:

    I don’t ever want to be in any weddings, ever again. I have spent probably $10K over the years on air fare, parties, gifts, clothing, etc. And then the best part of all – when the bride gets angry at you for not “doing it right”! Argh!

  • Lisa365 says:

    I’ve never been on a bridal party except when I was the bride. I flat-out told my girls to NOT spend a fortune on anything for me. My MOH threw me a bridal shower at her house, helped organize the stag & doe, but skipped out on a bachelorette party for me, which I was fine with (sort of). Just a night out at a pub would’ve been fine! Cheap for everyone. :-)

    My bridesmaids understood they had to buy their dresses & pay for makeup… shoes were up to them to decide (I wasn’t picky!) and I DEFINITELY asked them about what to do with their hair. Not only did I want them to feel comfortable, I didn’t want them to spend a fortune just for me. Honestly.

    All we did for the guys was reserve their tuxes. They were responsible for paying for all that, which was understood.

    I don’t think you’re complaining… but it does cost a lot to be part of the team! I’d suggest something much simpler for your friend’s b-lette party. No need to go all-out just for one night, especially if her “friends” can’t make it. :-) Hope it works out!!

  • This is precisely why I’m hoping no one else ever asks me to be in their wedding, and why I don’t want to have a wedding party to pressure into all this stuff.

    If your friend wants a bachelorette party you can’t afford, you need to let her know that. You can say, “my budget is $500 (or whatever), so anything you want that’s more than that, you will have to pay for.” You shouldn’t go into debt or be stressed financially so that she can have the wedding or bachelorette party of her dreams. (And yes, you’re also going to have to do the bridal shower, so you need to factor that in as well). You need to speak with her about this–I think she’s being a bit heavy-handed (think of it in terms of percentages–for the bachelorette party, you’ll be spending almost 1/3 of what she’s spending on the entire wedding. Would that make sense if it was a $10,000 wedding? Or a $50,000 wedding? If not, scale it back.)

  • Slinky says:

    Don’t even get me started on the costs of being a bridesmaid. What’s really sad is when the experience makes the whole friendship go sour. :(

    This is why for my wedding, I’d really like to pay for the girls’ dresses and hair. I want to be the anti-bridezilla. :)

  • Dawn says:

    I don’t think asking for a few dollars to help cover the cost is out of line at all. Although, since everyone is being frugal, I can understand why it is a lot for them to pay.

    The whole maid-of-honor thing has gotten out of hand. Making someone plan multiple parties, plus pay a ton of out of pocket costs – it is just ridiculous. Good luck with the wedding portion – hope that doesn’t break the bank too!

  • Money Funk says:

    Geesh! I am glad I am not a maid of honor. ;)

    And I don’t think that $30 is much to ask for. Especially for an extravegant night of fun! Cheap-Os!

  • mimi says:

    I was in 2 big weddings the summer I was in grad school. All of the bridesmaids pitched in to throw fun and not overly extravagant bachelorette parties/showers. You’re good to have hired a limo and made a club reservation for your duties — I would have never have done that. Having everyone pitch in and share a hotel room isn’t a big request.

    I think weddings have gotten out of hand. So too have baby showers. What happened to having a gathering at your mom’s or friends house? Why do we need limos and expensive clubs? We don’t — we just think we do.

  • mimi says:

    also — you don’t HAVE to get your hair and nails done. If I were you I’d do them myself.

  • fern says:

    i think it’s totally ridiculous to spend that kind of money, best friend or not.

    PS You don’t “have” to get your hair and nails done, just becus you’ll be photographed. I mean, really.

    Insane expenses. I would say “sorry,” no can do.

  • Kristy says:

    @ Courtney – She didn’t want a bridal shower, so I got lucky. I definitely agree that being a bridesmaid sucks! LOL. I’ve never been to a wedding and my first has to be this kind of the experience. I’m probably ruined for life now!

    @ 444 – Nothing wrong with a modest wedding, and it’s not like I can’t afford the above. But, I just felt that some of her friends were being a bit ridiculous. It wasn’t like I asked them to split it evenly, and frankly, I expected a bit more gratitude from the bride herself. It just seemed expected and that’s the part that pisses me off the most.

    @ Ashley – I told my friend that I wasn’t going to be able to much more for her after all I’ve put into the wedding and the bachelorette party. To my way of thinking, this bachelorette party was her wedding and birthday present all rolled into one since the bday is next month. I told her that and she was cool with it. It’s not that I can’t really afford it, I can, it’s just that I really think some of her other friends should have pitched in. They also tried to get drinks under my tab, too, which was below the belt. Nice surprise to them when I said no and made them take their own tabs.

    @ Christine – My personal feeling on long distance weddings is that the bride should pay for the ticket. When I get married, I intend to get married on a beach in Hawaii and fully plan to cover airfare for the wedding party and my parents – maybe his parents, we’ll see..hehehe. At any rate, if you ask someone out of state to be in the wedding, it’s only right to pay for the ticket, but maybe that’s just me. At the very least, you should offer to buy their dress.

    @ Lisa – I would agree with you except I don’t envision a bridal party as being part of a team. This is her show and she’s calling the shots. I’m just shelling out for them.

    @ Little Miss Moneybags – It’s not a budget issue. I can afford the $1000. It’s really that I wasn’t prepared for this to cost so much money, and that it was just expected I would do it. They’ve paid for the best man because they want to make sure all he has to do is show up. Her fiance planned his own bachelor party. But, they know that I’m not unreliable, so they just expected that I would take care of this. That’s really what gets me, the expectation that I would just spend this money and then it not being appreciated.

    @ Slinky – Yes, this experience has put our friendship in a new direction, that’s for sure. I’ll be glad when this is all said and done.

    @ Dawn – I agree, there’s a lot of pressure on us maid of honor’s that’s just completely unnecessary. And, if the roles were reversed, I wouldn’t be expecting this kind of thing. But, the wedding is this Saturday, so it’s almost over.

    @ Money Funk – LOL. Thank you!

    @ Mimi – It’s not that I thought we’d need it, it’s just something nice I wanted to do for my friend. And no, I don’t HAVE to get my hair and nails done, but it just makes it easier. I will probably do my own hair, but my nails need to be done anyway, so it just makes sense to go ahead and get them done.

    @ fern – LOL. I’m a very generous friend and I really don’t mind doing these things overall. My complaint is more so about the expectation that I would do it, and then not receiving the support from her other friends. To be honest, I should have just gone with the party bus, it would have been cheaper!

    Thanks everyone for all your replies! The bachelorette party was great, we had a good time, and now it’s almost time for the wedding. Yikes! Keep your fingers crossed for me. I’ll update you on the whole story after the wedding!

  • I’ve been in three weddings and have had to pay for my clothes, shoes, make up hair, etc. I think the bride in each one gave a small gift as a thank you to her attendants. I was MOH once and did throw the bridal shower, but the bachelorette party was on someone else. Maybe a close relative of the bride could help with the bridal shower?

    I’ve got some years on you and am grateful now that my friends who are getting married are usually on their second marriage and not into all that fuss that they did the 1st time around. I can get away with just a nice small gift!

    I think you went above and beyond as a friend.

  • J. Money says:

    yikes!!! i won’t even start on this as i know it’ll get crazy, but i’m hoping it all turns out for the best :) I should actually send this to my wife, she gets all kinds of riled up on this stuff! haha…

  • Honey, that is why I never, ever want to become a bridesmaid or maid of honour.

    Seriously.

    I saw that one coming back in the day. Paying for the dress you don’t want to ever wear again – $250. Shoes, Hair, Makeup.

    It is TOTALLY flaky that they paid for the guy and not for you. I’d be damn pissed at that. You have to be fair, esp since girls go through more expenses with makeup/hair than guys do.

    and shoes.

    Guys can wear their old black shoes from way back when, but girls can’t if you force them to wear a different or odd coloured dress then you want them to wear shoes to match.

    WTF.

    So mad on your behalf now.

    If I ever had a wedding, it’d be if I paid for the bridal party’s outfits and then they just helped me plan the day.

    And the bachelorette? “Friends” refusing to pay $30? That’s total BS.

  • [...] Master Your Card: The Cost of Being A Good Friend [...]

  • 444 says:

    I must come from a different cultural viewpoint because I don’t understand why a friend would be expected to pay anything toward someone else’s wedding.

    Don’t get me started on the modern wedding “industry.”

  • This is why I cut the shower and traveled TO my friends for my bachelorette party. Oh, and paid for the maids’ dresses. It’s just insane. We need a solution to bridesmaid dresses, for real. Every time you see that dress, you will resent this wedding.

  • Oh, and bachelorette parties are supposed to be FREE, if you’re doing it right! Forget the limo, just get guys to buy you drinks all night. That’s the point!

  • Ginger says:

    Ugh, I can totally relate. This sounds spot on to what I had to go through with my best friend… except that I spent even MORE and wasn’t even her maid of honour.

    All her “friends” bailed at the last moment, too. Me and the other gal (who at least was the maid of honour) had to pick up the costs for everything. In the end, all of her ridiculous wedding shenanigans cost me over $1500. And I really didn’t get anything out of it either except for heat stroke and a cheap pair of earrings.

    I feel your pain, truly I do. You can check out my posts on my drama on my blog under the wedding tag.

    Stay strong, my friend!

  • Beth says:

    @ dogatemyfinances — You’re totally right! I cringed and got angry all over again every time I saw my bridesmaid’s dress. It was a nice enough dress, but the colour was horrendous on me and the style didn’t look good on her other bridesmaids. She didn’t care about our feelings — just how we would make her look. (Why can’t some people understand that beautiful bridesmaids are a compliment to the bride?)

    I hated that dress until the lady at the local bridal shop told me about a charity that collects formal dresses for under-privileged or disabled teens so they can go to their prom or graduations. (It promotes a sense of belonging, and lets the girls participate in normal rights-of-passage).

    My advice to anyone else who doesn’t like their dress — Send it out into the world to do some good :) It feels great.

    (Karen, I’m glad I came across your comment on Bargaineering! I’m looking forward to reading more of your posts).

  • Here’s the thing. Brides-to-be and their mammas have evolved the “wedding” from a sacramental celebration into an entire industry which often includes uncontrolled spending by all concerned. In fact, the actual marriage part of the wedding has become mostly meaningless, with some of them actually being phony events staged just so that a ginormous wedding reception can follow. Often we hear complaints about bridesmaid dresses, lousy gifts, cheap friends, cost-shifting, you name it. Brides are driving the train – only they can stop it.

  • Sense says:

    OMG! that’s some ridiculousness right there! the whole best man thing (WOW he sounds like a trainwreck) aside, it’s totally unfair to expect you to pay for everything yourself. Yes, you should be ‘in charge’ and probably put more time/effort into the whole bach party, but i think the cost should be split evenly between HER BEST FRIENDS. that’s what they are, right? if not, why the heck are they in her wedding??

    That is A LOT of money…the first commenter spent $2K as maid of honor? WHOA. who has that kind of money to spare??

    i had to take over a maid of honor’s duties once (the real maid of honor suddenly disapproved drinking and wouldn’t do the bach party), and i ended up printing signs on my parent’s computer and sticking them up in the bride’s favorite bar (with permission from the bar owner), and baking a cake and sticking gummy peni on it for fun. we bbq’d at the bride’s friends house, then drove to the decorated bar. so much fun!! and pretty dang cheap. the bride loved it…but then again she’s pretty frugal and down to earth herself so I know she didn’t expect much.

    I know you want to make your friend’s night wonderful, but you gotta draw the line somewhere. if it were your wedding, wouldn’t you want her to say something to you if she were feeling like you do right now??

  • Beth says:

    When I was a maid of honour, the bride bought me a book about how to be the perfect bridesmaid as a birthday gift. Essentially, you’re not a good bridesmaid if you’re not spending tonnes of money on the bride and her big day, and you aren’t blindly bowing to her every whim.

    Unfortunately, the sense of entitlement when people get married is huge. What really sickens me about this whole industry is that women are taught that the only time we get to be in the spotlight or celebrate something is when we get married or have babies. This isn’t the 1950s.

  • [...] dollar amount is the magical mark that makes someone cheap. $10? $20? $30? I recently wrote about how much it costs to be a good friend. A few comments mentioned how cheap my friend’s friends were because they didn’t want [...]

  • Chariot says:

    I totally disagree with the tradition of the wedding party paying their own way-dress, shoes, etc. I believe it should be the bride and groom’s responsibility to pay for all those things. That is what I will be doing for my wedding, sorta. I’m letting the wedding party wear what they want. So if they choose to spend money on a new dress they can but it will definitly be something they would wear again.

    Unfortunately, I am a commited bridesmaid at 2 different weddings. How do you say no? I hope they don’t expect me to start hemoraging money! But I have an excuse ready–it will be here in 9 months.

  • Kevin says:

    $3,000.00 for a small wedding and they don’t have much money? My wife and I did all we could ourselves for our wedding which pretty much just left out the rings and the preacher. I would say we spent less than $200.00.
    We are just as married, have just a fond recollection of the day, and we didn’t put a financial burden on anyone.

Leave a comment!

Add your comment below, or trackback from your own site. You can also subscribe to these comments via RSS.

Be nice. Keep it clean. Stay on topic. No spam.

You can use these tags:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

This is a Gravatar-enabled weblog. To get your own globally-recognized-avatar, please register at Gravatar.